Writing Diagnostic: Make a Case
A short policy decision gives you a baseline for argument, organisation, register and language control.
Learning objective
Write an independent essay, then identify one strength and two priorities for the course.
Start with the independent writing task. After you save your attempt, this review opens.
Go to Exercise 3Model text
A college can improve access to study space by opening the library on Sundays or keeping it open late on weekdays. Discuss both measures and decide which should be tried first.
Extending library hours could make independent study easier for students who cannot rely on a quiet room at home. The college has two realistic options. Its choice should depend on when additional access would remove the greatest obstacle to regular study.
A Sunday opening would give students a substantial block of uninterrupted time. This is particularly valuable for anyone who needs to complete a project with classmates. However, students with weekend jobs or caring responsibilities would still struggle to make use of the building, and a single weekly session would do little to support short, frequent study.
Later weekday hours would allow students to stay on after lessons and finish work before going home. That continuity matters: someone who can spend an hour checking references straight after a seminar may avoid having to repeat the same preparation the following day. The benefit would be smaller for students whose last bus leaves early, so the closing time should be decided in consultation with the transport office.
On balance, the college should trial later closing on two weekdays. This would serve several different timetables without requiring an entire extra day of staffing. During the trial, the library could record use in the final hour and ask students whether they would otherwise have been able to study. Those answers would give the college a sounder basis for deciding whether Sunday opening should follow.
What to notice
- Notice how the introduction sets a criterion that the conclusion actually uses.
- Underline one reason, one example and one condition. Each serves a different purpose.
- Record a sentence that sounds like your own strongest writing and one you would now revise.
Four questions to review your writing
- Content
Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader? - Communicative Achievement
Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose? - Organisation
Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references? - Language
Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?
Writing Diagnostic: Make a Case
Start with the independent writing task. After you save your attempt, this review opens.
Go to Exercise 3Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.
1.Which phrase could replace “That continuity matters” while preserving the explanation that follows?
2.What would be lost if “The benefit would be smaller” were changed to “Students will be unable to benefit”?
3.What does “whether they would otherwise have been able to study” help distinguish?
Writing Diagnostic: Make a Case
Start with the independent writing task. After you save your attempt, this review opens.
Go to Exercise 3Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.
1.Both proposals offer more time in the library. Which comparison explains the writer’s choice?
2.Which pair of observations would let the college tell whether the trial was creating new opportunities to study?
3.A draft describes both library options and concludes “Sunday is more useful”. What change would make that judgement defensible?
Apply the skill
After comparing drafts, record one strength and two priorities. Quote a short phrase as evidence of the strength. For each priority, name one revision you could actually make. Use the same four criteria when you review the final mock essay.
Compare with a possible response
My strongest move is making the judgement explicit with “regular access should come first”. In revision, I would name who still depends on campus facilities and replace “it would help everyone” with a claim about students who share a device.
Writing Diagnostic: Make a Case
Allow 45 minutes for independent writing. The timer starts when you open the prompt. Save your draft to open the review.
Your task
A college has funds for either a weekend shuttle to campus or a laptop loan scheme. Write an essay for a college tutor discussing both measures. Decide which would improve access to study more and justify your choice.
220–260 words.
Your draft
Your draft saves in this browser. If you request AI feedback, the draft is sent for formative review.