Synthesise Sources for a Decision Brief
Combine sources by issue and show what each source can establish before making a recommendation.
Learning objective
Write a brief that integrates sources around a decision and makes the boundary between evidence and recommendation clear.
Model text
A six-week flexible-start trial recorded 84 per cent on-time case completion, compared with 78 per cent in the previous six weeks. Staffing was also higher during the trial. A staff survey drew 18 voluntary replies from 44 employees. Thirteen valued flexibility, and several late-shift staff reported thin cover at opening. Brief the operations lead.
The trial suggests that flexible starts could be retained, provided the team protects cover at the beginning of the day. The operations log and the staff survey address different questions, so the apparent improvement in one does not remove the concern raised by the other.
The log shows that on-time completion rose from 78 to 84 per cent during the trial. Staffing also increased, making it difficult to isolate the effect of start times. The survey nevertheless indicates that flexibility mattered to some staff: 13 of the 18 people who replied valued it. Because participation was voluntary, the responses cannot establish how widespread that preference was across the team.
Several late-shift colleagues reported thin cover at opening. That observation can coexist with better overall completion if cases are cleared later in the day. It is therefore worth tracking waiting times in the first hour separately from daily completion.
Retain flexible starts for another month with a minimum opening rota. If waiting times stabilise and completion remains steady, the arrangement would merit a longer trial under comparable staffing conditions.
What to notice
- Group the evidence around a decision. Show where the sources address different outcomes.
- Choose attribution verbs that reflect the source: a log records, a survey respondent reports and a brief may infer.
- Use a conditional recommendation when evidence supports further testing.
Four questions to review your writing
- Content
Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader? - Communicative Achievement
Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose? - Organisation
Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references? - Language
Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?
Synthesise Sources for a Decision Brief
Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.
1.Why does the writer distinguish “shows” from “indicates”?
2.What does “can coexist” express?
3.What does “under comparable staffing conditions” qualify?
Synthesise Sources for a Decision Brief
Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.
1.Why is the waiting-time measure introduced?
2.Which report of the survey is faithful?
3.Which recommendation responds to both the completion figures and the reported difficulty at opening?
Apply the skill
Write a sentence integrating both sources in the new brief. Then add a sentence explaining a difference in what they can establish.
Read the writing brief
Give the service manager a decision brief on whether to retain online chat alongside the phone line. Reconcile the capacity figures with what clients report, explain the limits of both sources and recommend a way to handle simple and document-heavy requests. Name one measure that could test your decision.
Source A · Operations note
The team closed 410 help requests in the first month of the online chat pilot, compared with 350 in the preceding month. The manager described this as an improvement in capacity, but two part-time staff joined for the trial and handled requests across both channels. The records count requests closed through chat and by phone together. They do not show which were answered at particular times or whether a client who moved from chat to phone was recorded twice. Several staff members have proposed directing routine queries to chat so that advisers can spend longer on cases involving documents.
Source B · Interview summary
Eight of the 12 clients interviewed after completing a chat said the service was convenient, particularly when asking a short question while at work. Four described difficulty explaining documents in a text box. One said the exchange was helpful until the adviser needed to see how two documents related to each other. Participants were recruited at the end of successful chat sessions, so the interviews exclude people who left the queue or abandoned the channel. The interviewer recommends retaining a visible phone option for complex cases and asking users who change channels what led to that decision.
Compare with a possible response
The service handled more requests during the pilot, while the interviews suggest that chat was convenient for some short queries and difficult for some document-heavy requests. The records capture overall activity. The interviews illuminate particular experiences without showing how common they were across callers and chat users.
Synthesise Sources for a Decision Brief
Your task
Give the service manager a decision brief on whether to retain online chat alongside the phone line. Reconcile the capacity figures with what clients report, explain the limits of both sources and recommend a way to handle simple and document-heavy requests. Name one measure that could test your decision.
Source A · Operations note
The team closed 410 help requests in the first month of the online chat pilot, compared with 350 in the preceding month. The manager described this as an improvement in capacity, but two part-time staff joined for the trial and handled requests across both channels. The records count requests closed through chat and by phone together. They do not show which were answered at particular times or whether a client who moved from chat to phone was recorded twice. Several staff members have proposed directing routine queries to chat so that advisers can spend longer on cases involving documents.
Source B · Interview summary
Eight of the 12 clients interviewed after completing a chat said the service was convenient, particularly when asking a short question while at work. Four described difficulty explaining documents in a text box. One said the exchange was helpful until the adviser needed to see how two documents related to each other. Participants were recruited at the end of successful chat sessions, so the interviews exclude people who left the queue or abandoned the channel. The interviewer recommends retaining a visible phone option for complex cases and asking users who change channels what led to that decision.
170–220 words.
Your draft
Your draft saves in this browser. If you request AI feedback, the draft is sent for formative review.