Revise a Portfolio and Demonstrate Transfer
Improve one earlier piece and show that the same writing decision works on a new brief.
Learning objective
Produce an independent brief and a revision memo with concrete evidence of progress from an earlier draft.
Model text
A centre's quiet study sessions attract adults preparing for qualifications. Families want a place where they can work together. There is space for one room on weekday evenings. The manager needs a tested arrangement. Write a decision brief.
The centre should trial separate quiet and collaborative periods on two weekday evenings. This would test whether the same room can serve both groups without asking either to work under conditions that make participation difficult.
Adults preparing for qualifications need time to concentrate. Keeping the room quiet for the whole evening would meet that need but give families nowhere to work together. Setting aside a collaborative period would offer a predictable time for families to attend. The transition matters: someone who arrives near the end of quiet study should know how long that period will last before choosing to stay.
For a four-week trial, keep the room quiet for the first hour and offer collaborative use in the second. Post the hours online and at the entrance, and ask a staff member to explain the arrangement when people book. If one group can attend only at the time assigned to the other, the centre could reverse the order on one evening and compare use.
The manager should record attendance during each period and ask visitors who leave early why they did so. Similar attendance in the two periods would be encouraging, while repeated departures around the transition would indicate that an adjustment is needed. The next decision should be based on who is able to use the room and whether they can do the work they came to do.
An example of a short revision memo with a before-and-after quotation.
I revised the recommendation in my first report. The draft ended with “We should improve communication.” In the revision, I wrote “For four weeks, add the floor and a visible landmark to each booking confirmation, then count requests for directions.” The change names the action and makes the outcome observable. I kept the qualification about the small interview group because it still limits what the manager can infer. In the new brief I used the same principle when I specified what the centre should record during each period. My next priority is to distinguish a plausible cause from a result in every report conclusion.
What to notice
- Choose an earlier draft whose revision you can show with short quotations. Keep a copy before making changes and add both versions under Portfolio evidence.
- Compare your diagnostic essay with the essay from the Cambridge mock using the same four criteria. Quote evidence of one improvement and identify an aspect you still want to develop.
- Apply one revision principle on the fresh task. Download the portfolio to keep the two versions, new brief and revision memo together.
Four questions to review your writing
- Content
Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader? - Communicative Achievement
Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose? - Organisation
Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references? - Language
Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?
Revise a Portfolio and Demonstrate Transfer
Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.
1.What boundary does “without asking either to work under conditions that make participation difficult” place on the proposal?
2.Why does the brief ask visitors who “leave early” for a reason?
3.What does the memo's phrase “it still limits what the manager can infer” explain?
Revise a Portfolio and Demonstrate Transfer
Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.
1.Which revision shows the greatest change in what a reader can do with a recommendation?
2.Which example shows transfer of the specific revision principle in the memo?
3.Which portfolio note provides the clearest evidence that a particular revision improved a text?
Apply the skill
Pick one earlier draft, save the original, and revise one substantial element. Retain both versions and bring a short quotation from each into your memo.
Read the writing brief
Write a decision brief for the hall manager. Recommend a four-week arrangement that reserves enough help for first-time visitors and reduces avoidable waiting for regular users. Explain the trade-off, define staff or volunteer responsibilities and propose how to evaluate the arrangement.
The neighbourhood hall has one reception area and no budget for another attendant. First-time visitors often need a detailed explanation of where to go. Regular visitors need quicker check-in. A volunteer is available for the first 20 minutes of each evening session.
Compare with a possible response
Original: “We should make it easier for visitors.” Revision: “For four weeks, a volunteer should guide first-time visitors at the start of the session while the attendant checks in regular users.” This gives the manager a change to test and makes each role clear.
Revise a Portfolio and Demonstrate Transfer
Your task
Write a decision brief for the hall manager. Recommend a four-week arrangement that reserves enough help for first-time visitors and reduces avoidable waiting for regular users. Explain the trade-off, define staff or volunteer responsibilities and propose how to evaluate the arrangement.
The neighbourhood hall has one reception area and no budget for another attendant. First-time visitors often need a detailed explanation of where to go. Regular visitors need quicker check-in. A volunteer is available for the first 20 minutes of each evening session.
220–270 words.
Your draft
Portfolio evidence
Paste the full original and revised versions of an earlier course task. Use short quotations from these texts in your memo.
Revision memo
Write 100–140 words. Name the earlier task and the aspect you revised. Quote a short extract before and after the change, explain the effect on the reader and point to where you used the same principle in the new brief.
Memo draft
Your draft saves in this browser. If you request AI feedback, the draft is sent for formative review.