C1 Writing · Lesson 04

Qualify Claims and Address Objections

1 / 4 stages

A convincing argument gives a serious objection its due and shows how it changes the recommendation.

Argument essay 55 min 220–260 words

Learning objective

Write a balanced argument in which a counterargument leads to a practical qualification.

Model text

Should teams be required to spend one day a week together in the office? Examine the benefit and a credible objection, then give a qualified recommendation.

A shared office day can make useful conversations easier to arrange. A blanket requirement, however, risks turning a means of improving collaboration into an attendance rule with an unclear purpose. Teams should agree on what needs to happen together before they decide how often to meet.

Supporters of a fixed day have a reasonable case. If project members know they can speak to one another in person on Tuesday, they may resolve questions that would otherwise generate long exchanges. A regular day also reduces the work of coordinating calendars. These advantages are most persuasive when the work genuinely depends on quick collective decisions and when the relevant people are actually present.

The strongest objection concerns who bears the cost. An employee with a long commute may spend hours travelling to join video calls with people based elsewhere. A monthly day planned around decisions, mentoring and workshops would capture more of the benefit for a geographically dispersed team. A team training new colleagues may reasonably need to meet more often, at least while those colleagues are settling in.

The company should ask each team to publish a short rationale for its schedule and review it after two months. The test should be whether colleagues can identify choices they made or skills they learned through meeting together. Where they cannot, the schedule deserves reconsideration.

What to notice

  1. State the strongest version of a credible objection and identify the circumstances in which it holds.
  2. Use scope markers such as “where”, “at least while” and “when”. Each should carry a specific distinction.
  3. Let the objection affect your final proposal, even if the central position remains.
Four questions to review your writing
  • Content
    Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader?
  • Communicative Achievement
    Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose?
  • Organisation
    Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references?
  • Language
    Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?
Exercises:
Exercise 1 · Language in the model

Qualify Claims and Address Objections

1 / 4 stages

Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.

1.Which condition must hold for the shared day to reduce a long exchange of messages about a project?

2.What does “at least while those colleagues are settling in” leave open?

3.How does “the schedule deserves reconsideration” keep the ending focused on the decision?

Exercise 2 · Organisation, purpose and revision

Qualify Claims and Address Objections

1 / 4 stages

Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.

1.Which sentence would serve as the hinge from the strongest benefit to an evaluation of its limits?

2.Shops on a proposed car-free street have no rear entrance for deliveries. Which response to that objection most closely follows the model’s reasoning?

3.What review evidence would be most relevant to the model's judgement?

Apply the skill

Write the strongest fair objection to your likely position in one sentence. Add a condition that addresses it and say how that changes your recommendation.

Read the writing brief

Your town is considering an annual car-free weekend in its centre. Write an essay for a community education journal explaining the main benefit, addressing a credible objection and recommending conditions under which the idea should be tried.

Compare with a possible response

Shops with no rear entrance may be unable to receive essential stock during a full road closure. I would therefore trial the car-free weekend with short loading windows before the busiest hours and ask affected shops whether the windows are workable.

Exercise 3 · Independent writing

Qualify Claims and Address Objections

1 / 4 stages

Your task

Your town is considering an annual car-free weekend in its centre. Write an essay for a community education journal explaining the main benefit, addressing a credible objection and recommending conditions under which the idea should be tried.

220–260 words.

Your draft

Self-review checklist

Read each point and check it against your draft. Keep a note of anything you want to revise.

Review by criterion
  • Content
    Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader?
  • Communicative Achievement
    Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose?
  • Organisation
    Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references?
  • Language
    Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?

Your draft saves in this browser. If you request AI feedback, the draft is sent for formative review.