C1 Writing · Lesson 05

Guide the Reader Through a Complex Argument

1 / 4 stages

A reader follows complex reasoning more easily when each paragraph picks up and advances a clear idea.

Comparative essay 55 min 220–260 words

Learning objective

Develop a comparison whose key terms, paragraph sequence and final judgement are easy to track.

Model text

A town can fund shade along its shopping street or extend opening hours at a cooling centre. Compare the measures and decide which should be the immediate priority.

For residents who have nowhere cool to spend a hot afternoon, a town's response must work during the next heatwave. Extending cooling-centre hours and adding shade along the shopping street both offer relief, but they protect people at different points in the day.

On the street, temporary canopies would reduce exposure for people waiting for buses or shopping for essentials. The relief would be immediate once the canopies were installed, and it would be available without anyone changing their route. Its reach would nevertheless be limited to particular stretches of pavement and to the hours when the sun was high.

That limitation matters for residents whose flats remain hot after sunset. Extending the cooling centre's hours would give these residents a place to recover in the evening, when the shopping-street canopies would offer little additional protection. A later service would, however, be useful only if people knew about it and could get home afterwards. Posted hours and coordination with the last bus would therefore be part of the measure itself.

The town should extend the centre's opening hours before the next heatwave, with the travel arrangements in place from the first evening. Street shade would still be a worthwhile second step, particularly near bus stops. The two measures could eventually complement one another, provided the immediate need for evening relief is met first.

What to notice

  1. Name the point a paragraph inherits and the new point it adds. Repeat a key term if a pronoun would be ambiguous.
  2. Choose a bridge that conveys the logic. A limitation is more informative than a general transition.
  3. In revision, read only paragraph openings and the final judgement. Check whether the direction is evident.
Four questions to review your writing
  • Content
    Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader?
  • Communicative Achievement
    Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose?
  • Organisation
    Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references?
  • Language
    Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?
Exercises:
Exercise 1 · Language in the model

Guide the Reader Through a Complex Argument

1 / 4 stages

Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.

1.What does “Its reach” refer to?

2.What does “That limitation” carry into paragraph three?

3.Why would replacing “therefore” with “in addition” weaken the link in the third paragraph?

Exercise 2 · Organisation, purpose and revision

Guide the Reader Through a Complex Argument

1 / 4 stages

Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.

1.Which reorder would most obscure the reasoning?

2.A paragraph mentions later opening and clearer signs. You want the next sentence to explain the benefit of the signs in particular. Which version keeps the reference clear?

3.What does the final reference to bus stops add to the recommendation?

Apply the skill

Draft four topic sentences for your next essay. Read them in order and revise one transition so it names a real link between ideas.

Read the writing brief

A council can improve winter walking access by gritting routes around clinics or repairing lighting on footpaths to public transport. Write an essay comparing both measures. Select an immediate priority and justify it with a clear sequence of connected reasons.

Compare with a possible response

Winter access should be judged by which journeys people cannot easily postpone. Gritting would help patients on slippery clinic approaches. That protection is limited to icy periods, whereas unlit footpaths affect anyone travelling after dark. The priority therefore depends on which risk currently prevents more essential journeys.

Exercise 3 · Independent writing

Guide the Reader Through a Complex Argument

1 / 4 stages

Your task

A council can improve winter walking access by gritting routes around clinics or repairing lighting on footpaths to public transport. Write an essay comparing both measures. Select an immediate priority and justify it with a clear sequence of connected reasons.

220–260 words.

Your draft

Self-review checklist

Read each point and check it against your draft. Keep a note of anything you want to revise.

Review by criterion
  • Content
    Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader?
  • Communicative Achievement
    Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose?
  • Organisation
    Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references?
  • Language
    Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?

Your draft saves in this browser. If you request AI feedback, the draft is sent for formative review.