C1 Writing · Lesson 03

Build an Argument with Evidence

1 / 4 stages

Evidence has value when its details support the claim and the reader can see the connection.

Evidence-based essay 55 min 220–260 words

Learning objective

Use concrete examples to explain a causal mechanism and avoid generalising beyond the available evidence.

Model text

Should schools use automated writing feedback before a teacher responds? Consider which kinds of feedback should be automated and where teacher judgement matters.

Automated feedback could help students revise more often, especially when the alternative is a long wait for comments. Its educational value depends on which decisions are delegated to the system and which remain with the learner and the teacher.

Repeated low-stakes practice is one plausible benefit. A student who notices that several sentences have unclear pronoun references can try two revisions and compare how the system responds. The speed of that cycle may make revision feel like part of drafting. The same example tells us little about whether the student can spot unclear references independently. In a classroom trial, a later task completed without prompts would therefore provide better evidence of learning than the number of corrections accepted.

Teachers are especially important where the writer has a defensible choice to make. An automated suggestion to move a qualification into the introduction might be sensible in an essay whose position is concealed. In a review, delaying that judgement until the reader has seen an example may be an effective deliberate choice. A teacher who knows the task can ask the learner to explain the effect of each version.

Schools should therefore use automated comments for reversible experiments in early drafts and reserve teacher time for decisions about meaning, audience and structure. Whether this division is worthwhile should be judged by what students can eventually revise on their own.

What to notice

  1. Test each example against the claim it is meant to support. Explain the connection in a sentence.
  2. Distinguish a plausible classroom example from an observed result. Use conditional or modal forms where appropriate.
  3. Specify what further evidence would allow a stronger claim.
Four questions to review your writing
  • Content
    Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader?
  • Communicative Achievement
    Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose?
  • Organisation
    Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references?
  • Language
    Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?
Exercises:
Exercise 1 · Language in the model

Build an Argument with Evidence

1 / 4 stages

Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.

1.Why is “plausible” important in the second paragraph?

2.Which outcome would provide the best evidence that the student learned to resolve unclear pronoun references?

3.Which paraphrase retains the distinction the writer draws between the essay and the review?

Exercise 2 · Organisation, purpose and revision

Build an Argument with Evidence

1 / 4 stages

Use the model from the explanation. Aim for 3 correct answers.

1.Which statement turns the example about pronoun references into a proposal for collecting evidence?

2.Which sentence most directly explains how peer feedback helps a learner improve clarity?

3.Which conclusion stays within the argument?

Apply the skill

Write one 45–60-word evidence chain for the new task. Include a claim, a realistic example and a sentence explaining exactly what that example demonstrates.

Read the writing brief

A training centre wants to replace some in-person practice with recorded demonstrations. Write an essay for the training team discussing what recordings can teach effectively and what still requires supervised practice. Recommend a sensible balance.

Compare with a possible response

A recorded demonstration can help a trainee learn the order of a procedure. Someone preparing to check a machine can pause the recording and list each step. That shows how a recording can support recall. A supervisor still needs to observe whether the trainee notices an unexpected reading.

Exercise 3 · Independent writing

Build an Argument with Evidence

1 / 4 stages

Your task

A training centre wants to replace some in-person practice with recorded demonstrations. Write an essay for the training team discussing what recordings can teach effectively and what still requires supervised practice. Recommend a sensible balance.

220–260 words.

Your draft

Self-review checklist

Read each point and check it against your draft. Keep a note of anything you want to revise.

Review by criterion
  • Content
    Have I covered the brief and supported the points that matter to this reader?
  • Communicative Achievement
    Do the genre, tone and level of detail serve the intended reader and purpose?
  • Organisation
    Can the reader follow the progression, find the main point and understand references?
  • Language
    Are vocabulary and grammar precise, varied where useful, and consistently controlled?

Your draft saves in this browser. If you request AI feedback, the draft is sent for formative review.